Go away playoff gimmicks to MLB and preserve the NHL post-season simply the best way it’s


The present NHL playoff format is not excellent, however it’s compelling and produces a few of the most excellent moments in skilled sports activities. It is one factor the league has gotten proper, and there is no want to alter it.Ryan O’Reilly|Patrick Smith/Getty ImagesThe day after what would have been Invoice Veeck’s 106th birthday – look him up on Google, youngsters – information got here out that Main League Baseball just lately had a gathering with its Gamers’ Affiliation to debate including groups to the playoffs and a scheme during which higher-seeded playoff groups would select their first-round opponents in a reality-style tv occasion.
Cool. You go, baseball. Fourteen of 30 groups making the playoffs would merely elevate baseball to the extent of the opposite three North American skilled sports activities with regards to post-season participation. And hey, it could give extra groups the chance to play for an opportunity to bathe one another with beer after reaching an accomplishment akin to profitable a first-round playoff collection. So there’s that.
It’s simply that when issues like this occur, individuals get, you realize, concepts. Actually dumb ones like messing with the playoff format within the NHL, which occurs to be the very best in all {of professional} sports activities. There was a time when an absurd 16 of 21 groups made the post-season within the NHL. That was between 1979 when the league absorbed 4 groups from the World Hockey Affiliation and continued till the San Jose Sharks joined the league in 1991. In these 12 years, no workforce that had ever completed decrease than seventh general went on to win the Stanley Cup. Then the league began increasing and increasing some extra. However NHL commissioner Gary Bettman and the board of governors elected to carry the road on the variety of playoff groups. So when Seattle joins the league to turn out to be the 32nd workforce, precisely half the groups will make the playoffs and half gained’t.
The NHL has hit on a system that isn’t excellent, however it’s excellent. The primary two rounds of the NHL playoffs are each bit as compelling and chaotic as March Insanity. And as soon as groups get via that, they arrive to the conclusion that they’re solely midway to realizing the dream of profitable a Stanley Cup. You know the way they are saying the Stanley Cup is probably the most troublesome trophy to win in skilled sports activities? They’re proper.
Bettman and the house owners have thus far resisted the temptation to mess with the playoff format. The idea of play-in video games to resolve the ultimate playoff seeds in every convention has been proposed and, fortunately, shot down. In case you’re not adequate to be among the many prime three groups in your division or the subsequent two greatest groups within the convention after 82 regular-season video games, you don’t get invited to the occasion. That is the NHL, the very best league on this planet. Sorry, no participation trophies right here.
We get that the system isn’t excellent. For instance, the Carolina Hurricanes are at the moment on the skin wanting in with regards to the playoffs, largely as a result of the Metropolitan Division is so good and aggressive. If the Hurricanes have been within the Pacific Division, they’d be in first place. They’d be in third in the event that they have been within the Atlantic or Central. Giving a bye to every division winner, then seeding the subsequent seven groups no matter division would clear up that. However there was a time not way back when the scenario was reversed the place the Pacific was the Group of Loss of life and the Metro was decidedly weaker. These items are inclined to even out over time and the truth that it occurs mustn’t come on the expense of regional rivalries.
And that’s what individuals who need the NHL to alter its playoff format could be forgetting right here. The NHL is a regional sport, way over any of the opposite 4 on the North American panorama. Hockey followers usually tend to tune out after their groups get eradicated than in basketball, soccer or baseball. One of many complaints concerning the present format is that two glorious groups with related data stand probability of going through one another within the first or second spherical of the playoffs, thereby eliminating a high quality workforce by the point the playoffs are one quarter/one half completed.
You’ll want to level no additional than the Washington-Pittsburgh rivalry to see that. However right here’s the factor. Followers must reside with both the Capitals or the Penguins being eradicated within the second spherical, one thing that would conceivably occur this season, regardless of the very fact the Capitals and Penguins are at the moment the third- and fourth-best groups within the league. Similar factor may occur with the St. Louis Blues and Colorado Avalanche, who maintain down the fifth and sixth positions. However the big upside is that by having the playoff format this fashion, followers are nearly all the time assured a matchup towards a division rival within the first two rounds. Sure, one in all them goes residence early, however not less than you get to see the matchup.
And as for groups choosing their first-round playoff opponent, simply no. On the subject of that, let MLB be the Southern Professional League or the Seaforth Silver Stick or the Lethbridge Ice Breaker. There was a time when the Ontario League would enable first-place groups to both take a bye or play a first-round collection, conceivably so as to get extra residence dates and revenues, and there was a yr the Ottawa 67s selected to play within the first spherical and misplaced. It was a silly thought then and it stays one.
There are quite a lot of issues that must be modified concerning the NHL, however the playoff system will not be one in all them. That is one factor that Bettman and Co., have gotten proper. And if sanity prevails, they gained’t change a factor.
Need extra in-depth options and evaluation? Subscribe to The Hockey Information journal.
Tags: stanley cup playoffs, nhlConnect: Concerning the AuthorKen CampbellKen Campbell, The Hockey Information’ senior author, is in his second tour with the model after an eight-year stint as a beat reporter for the Maple Leafs for the Toronto Star. The Sudbury native as soon as tried out for the Ontario League’s Wolves as a 30-year-old. Evidently, it did not work out.

Leave A Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Accept Read More