Offseason Outlook: Houston Astros
MLBTR is publishing Offseason Outlooks for all 30 groups. Click on right here to learn the opposite entries on this collection.
A month in the past, the Astros got here inside a sport of successful their second World Sequence in three seasons. Now? They’re the topic of an investigation by MLB commissioner Rob Manfred’s workplace and will lose one of many sport’s greatest pitchers to free company.
Arbitration-Eligible Gamers (contract projections by way of MLBTR contributor Matt Swartz)
We’ll get this out of the best way up entrance: whereas the Astros have loads of roster wants to deal with this offseason, the first storyline proper now’s the league’s investigation into the digital sign-stealing accusations introduced forth in opposition to them, which stem again to the 2017 season. There are probably extreme ramifications for the Houston group if ample proof arises to show their guilt, however at this level the extent of these still-theoretical sanctions can’t be identified. This outlook will focus purely on the workforce’s roster and payroll outlook, as there’s no technique of figuring out precisely when, how or even when the Astros might be penalized by the commissioner’s workplace.
With that out of the best way, the most important wants dealing with the Astros group come within the rotation and behind the plate. Houston picked up Zack Greinke in a last-minute trade-deadline blockbuster, however Gerrit Cole and Wade Miley each reached free company at season’s finish. Robinson Chirinos and Martin Maldonado are each free brokers, too, leaving 26-year-old Garrett Stubbs as the one catcher on Houston’s 40-man roster. Clearly, that leaves president of baseball operations Jeff Luhnow and his employees with some work to do.
To what extent is possession prepared to spend to deal with these wants, although? Proprietor Jim Crane mentioned in early October that the Astros “choose to not” cross the $208MM luxurious tax barrier, although he cautioned that the workforce’s postseason displaying might affect that call. A run to Recreation 7 of the World Sequence absolutely put some additional money within the pipeline, however the strongest feedback Crane has made with regard to spending this winter got here earlier this month when discussing Cole’s free company: “We’re going to take a run at it. We don’t know if we are able to get to the place they need to get. [Agent Scott] Boras is hard to take care of.” A convincing cry of aggression, it was not, however that shouldn’t come as a lot of a shock. The probability that Cole has turn out to be too giant a bit to suit into this puzzle has been obvious for a while now.
The largest impediment for the Astros is that even assuming a non-tender of July acquisition Aaron Sanchez, whose 2020 standing is up within the air after shoulder surgical procedure, Houston’s payroll will high $200MM in 2020. The precise projections will range, as the precise quantity relies on arbitration-eligible gamers and on figuring out precisely what they owe Greinke. The D-backs are paying a reported $10.33MM of the $35MM owed to Greinke in 2020 and 2021 ($32MM base wage plus a $3MM cost of his pro-rated signing bonus), and $11MM of that yearly sum is deferred to 2022-26.
None of these payroll gymnastics matter for luxury-tax functions, although, as that calculation is extra simple and primarily based on the common annual worth of the workforce’s contractual obligations. Between assured contracts, arbitration projections, pre-arbitration gamers and cash put aside for participant advantages, Jason Martinez of Roster Useful resource has their present luxurious obligations at a whopping $238MM. Non-tendering Sanchez would trim $5.6MM of that, but it surely’s clear that the workforce’s offseason degree of exercise might be closely depending on whether or not Crane and his group can certainly abdomen what appears like a probably notable luxurious hit.
Given the workforce’s cloudy fiscal outlook, it’s maybe not stunning that Luhnow has already gone on file as stating that right-hander Jose Urquidy will “possible” be within the workforce’s rotation subsequent 12 months. He’ll be joined by a returning Lance McCullers Jr., and the membership has some upper-level depth in Rogelio Armenteros, Cionel Perez, Bryan Abreu and Forrest Whitley. However Whitley’s inventory is down after a depressing 2019 season, McCullers is one thing of a wild card in his first season again from Tommy John surgical procedure, and the workforce traded righties Corban Martin and J.B. Bukauskas to the D-backs within the Greinke swap. On the very least, one veteran stabilizer or would appear to be a prudent addition — even when it’s a low-cost add within the Brett Anderson or Homer Bailey mould. If the Astros need extra of an upside play, they might roll the cube on Josh Lindblom, Kwang-hyun Kim or Shun Yamaguchi as they give the impression of being to leap from the KBO (Lindblom, Kim) and NPB (Yamaguchi) to the Majors.
Behind the plate, a reunion with any variety of previous buddies can be logical: Chirinos, Maldonado and Jason Castro are all accessible in free company. The Mariners are reportedly exploring the marketplace for Omar Narvaez, who’s solely projected to obtain a modest $2.9MM wage in his first 12 months of arbitration. On the pricier aspect of issues, the Cubs might take heed to affords for Willson Contreras. Finally, whether or not it’s by way of commerce or free company, the Astros have so as to add a catcher or two; Stubbs hit simply .240/.332/.397 (79 wRC+) final 12 months in Triple-Some time the remainder of the league exploded with historic ranges of offensive output.
Round the remainder of the roster, issues look largely set. Yuli Gurriel, Jose Altuve, Carlos Correa and Alex Bregman will comprise the infield, whereas the outfield has Michael Brantley, George Springer, Josh Reddick, Jake Marisnick and Kyle Tucker within the combine. Rookie of the 12 months Yordan Alvarez will return to DH and will see some occasional reps in left or at first base. It’s a stacked lineup.
There’s a situation the place the Astros stick primarily in home for the beginning employees, choose up an inexpensive catcher and hope their core can keep wholesome sufficient to hold them to one more AL West championship. They might even look to shed a few of Reddick’s remaining $13MM and go together with the youthful, extra inexpensive Tucker in proper area. There’s sufficient expertise there, however counting on McCullers and a pair of younger arms to spherical out the beginning employees would depart the workforce with little depth, particularly within the occasion of an harm to Verlander or Greinke.
Frankly, nevertheless, it’s exhausting to see simply how this Astros roster might presumably be constructed to drop beneath the posh tax with out severely compromising its core. Barring a surprising commerce — e.g. Springer, Greinke — there simply aren’t many pure means to lowering payroll. As such, the very best plan of action might be to simply chunk the bullet and wade deep into luxury-tax waters. In spite of everything, the Astros will see Reddick, Brantley, Springer, Gurriel and Peacock all come off the books for the 2021 season. Greinke and Verlander will each be free brokers the next winter. That’s to not say Houston’s window is “closing,” however the present roster presents a superb shot at returning to postseason play (notably with just a few additions). A one-year dalliance into luxurious territory isn’t more likely to include particularly prolonged or regarding ramifications.
And if Houston is prepared to pay the posh tax, the market affords loads of intriguing mid-rotation arms that received’t require a $30MM+ annual wage like Cole or Stephen Strasburg finally will. A reunion with Dallas Keuchel or a pursuit of a mid-tier choice like Rick Porcello, Tanner Roark, Kyle Gibson or Michael Pineda would make loads of sense. Alternatively, the Astros might look to the commerce market to discover a much less dear choice. Jon Grey or Chris Archer have high-end uncooked stuff, and Houston has efficiently coaxed higher performances out of pitchers in related eventualities. The workforce had curiosity in Matthew Boyd on the commerce deadline and will look into him once more.
The pliability they’ve on the position-player aspect bodes properly for inventive additions, too. If the Astros have grown weary of Correa’s harm troubles, might they even make the most of him to accumulate beginning pitching assist and make a separate run at a high-end commerce goal? Francisco Lindor and Kris Bryant have already seen their names pop up in rumors, and the free-agent market isn’t quick on high quality third basemen if the workforce is snug with Bregman taking part in shortstop on a full-time foundation.
At this level, a authentic run at signing any of Cole, Strasburg or Anthony Rendon appears exhausting to fathom, because it’d really put the Astros into unprecedented luxurious tax territory. However there’s room for the workforce to shed some wage (Sanchez, Reddick, Chris Devenski, Jake Marisnick, maybe Roberto Osuna), nonetheless make just a few additions and easily be OK with dwelling within the second tier of penalization. (The max penalty any first-time CBT offender would pay for going proper as much as the cusp of the highest penalty tier can be $10.4MM.) It’ll be a advantageous line to stroll, however this Houston entrance workplace ought to be inventive sufficient to efficiently thread that needle.